Book review of Man and Superman: A Comedy and a Philosophy

by GEORGE BERNARD SHAW (Author)

Updated at: 21/01/2025

George Bernard Shaw's "Man and Superman: A Comedy and a Philosophy" is a vibrant and intellectually stimulating play that transcends the boundaries of conventional theatre. Following the unconventional romance between the determined Ann Whitefield and the intellectually arrogant John Tanner, the play masterfully intertwines witty dialogue with profound philosophical musings. Tanner's radical social views clash with Ann's unwavering pursuit, creating a dynamic tension that fuels the narrative. The iconic "Don Juan in Hell" dream sequence offers a breathtaking interlude of existential debate, showcasing Shaw's signature blend of humor and rigorous intellectual exploration of love, freedom, and the constraints of societal expectations. Prepare for a comedic yet deeply thought-provoking journey into the heart of human nature.

4.4 / 291 ratings

Review Man and Superman

Oh, Man and Superman! What a whirlwind of a read! George Bernard Shaw's brilliance truly shines through in this play, solidifying my love for his work. It's a fascinating blend of witty comedy and profound philosophical inquiry, a heady mix that keeps you constantly engaged. The central conflict between John Tanner, the intellectual bachelor, and Ann Whitefield, his cunning pursuer, is brilliantly executed. Their verbal sparring is a masterclass in dramatic dialogue, full of sharp wit and insightful commentary on love, freedom, and societal expectations.

The "Don Juan in Hell" sequence is simply unforgettable. This extended dream sequence is a powerhouse of existential debate, a truly captivating intellectual feast. Shaw's ability to seamlessly weave together humor and weighty philosophical discussions is remarkable. It's a section that demands your attention and rewards you with stimulating ideas about life, death, and the nature of existence. I found myself pondering these concepts long after I finished reading.

Now, about my experience with the specific copy I purchased... well, that's a slightly different story. While owning an early 1904 edition is undeniably exciting for a book collector – and a testament to Shaw’s enduring appeal – the condition wasn't as advertised. Let's just say my expectations were higher regarding its preservation. It's readable, certainly, but the description of "good condition" was a generous stretch. I'm not overly fussy, happy to give a classic a gentle wipe-down, but the pre-existing pencil marks and overall wear and tear were disappointing, especially given the price point. It's a lesson learned about online book purchases – caveat emptor!

However, the book vendor's shortcomings couldn't completely overshadow the literary masterpiece itself. Shaw's insightful, sometimes inflammatory, dedication (which I found to be quite amusing!) is a perfect introduction to the play’s bold spirit. The play tackles complex themes with intelligence and wit, engaging the reader in a stimulating intellectual journey. I found the play’s satirical undertones particularly amusing, reflecting, as it does, societal norms and expectations of its time. Even now, many of the dynamics between John and Ann resonate, showing how timeless some aspects of human interaction are. Though the conclusion might be somewhat predictable, the journey to get there is anything but.

Despite the less-than-ideal condition of my copy, I wholeheartedly recommend Man and Superman. It's a truly rewarding experience for anyone interested in intellectual drama, insightful social commentary, or simply a clever and engaging story. Just maybe, find a more reliable book vendor! Four and a half stars for the play itself, zero stars for the bookselling experience – a testament to the enduring power of great literature to transcend even the most frustrating of purchases.

See more: Honest review of A Thousand and One Afternoons in Chicago